OFFICE HOURS: 9AM - 5PM MON TO FRI
A non-compete agreement can protect the brand, customer relationships, and confidential information that make a franchise system valuable. However, these agreements often become a source of conflict when that relationship ends. Former franchisees may challenge the restrictions, while franchisors may need to enforce them to protect the rest of the system.
Every non-compete dispute depends on the language of the agreement, the applicable state law, and the specific facts of the case. As franchisors, it is important to treat these provisions as more than standard contract language. A carefully drafted and consistently enforced non-compete agreement gives you a much stronger position if a dispute arises. We help franchisors create agreements that stand up to scrutiny and take prompt action when former franchisees violate their obligations.
One of the most common reasons for a non-compete dispute involves the scope of the restriction itself. A former franchisee may argue that the agreement limits competition more than necessary or prevents them from earning a living. The franchisor, on the other hand, may believe the restrictions are reasonable because they protect legitimate business interests.
Courts often look at factors such as the geographic area covered by the agreement and the length of the restriction when determining if it is reasonable. We work with franchisors to draft non-compete provisions that balance strong protection with the legal standards that courts expect.
Many disputes begin when a former franchisee opens or joins a competing business shortly after leaving the franchise system. In some cases, the new business offers nearly identical products or services in the same market. Even if the former franchisee changes the business name or branding, the operation may still compete directly with the franchise system. We help franchisors evaluate these situations quickly and pursue appropriate legal remedies when necessary.
Franchise systems depend on proprietary information, from customer data to secret recipes. A former franchisee who uses that information to compete can gain an unfair advantage, which is one of the main reasons franchise systems use non-compete provisions in the first place.
Disputes frequently arise when a franchisor believes confidential information continues to benefit a competing business after the franchise relationship ends. Even if the former franchisee does not copy documents directly, using knowledge gained through the franchise system may violate contractual obligations under certain circumstances. We help franchisors identify potential misuse of confidential information and determine the most effective way to protect valuable business assets.
Geographic restrictions often become the focus of non-compete litigation. A franchise agreement may prohibit a former franchisee from operating within a certain distance of the former location or another franchise territory. Problems then arise when the parties disagree about how those boundaries apply.
For example, a former franchisee may argue that the new business falls outside the restricted area, while the franchisor may interpret the agreement differently. It is important to rely on legal counsel who can draft an agreement that clearly spells out the geographical limitations.
The duration of a non-compete agreement often becomes another point of disagreement. A franchisor may view the restriction as necessary to protect goodwill and allow another franchise location to establish itself. A former franchisee may argue that the restriction lasts longer than necessary. Where a system operates in several states, the safer course is to draft to the shortest presumptively reasonable period in the states that matter most and to make the term severable, so that a court can shorten it rather than strike it.
There are many common reasons for franchise non-compete agreement disputes, and it is important to be prepared for all of them. At Franchise.Law, we are focused on helping franchisors get the legal support they need to thrive. Reach out today to learn more.